Is antisemitism protected on this site?
No, just as the slandering of other users is not protected.
This whole sorry affair started with:
Which country offers citizenship based on religious conversion?” Probably none except for the example in your question, as such an approach would likely be considered discriminatory.
I disagree with this opinion (i.e. it is not likely), because religious discrimination is based in treating a person or group differently because of the particular beliefs which they hold about a religion. The Law of Return is also about ethnic background ('people with one or more Jewish grandparent').
Had you pointed this out at this point, the discussion would have probably ended.
Instead of that an immature, childish, tit for tat starts with half baked historical samples (which are factualy correct, but beside the point) that leads nowhere.
At this point, you start making unfounded claims about the other users supposed motive:
The only reason you think the Israeli law of return is discriminatory is because it is Israeli.
As I mentioned before, similar laws exist in many countries, including many countries in Europe. In fact, the UK gives preferential immigration rights to people with British ancestry as well. So I really don't understand why, other than antisemitism, you'd single out the Israeli one. But... antisemitism is a strong force for many.
Had you read the link that yourself supplied in your answer properly (The Israeli Law of Return), all of this could have been avoided.
I agree with your answer and many of your initial statements:
There are some countries with similar laws (Italy, Ireland, Germany - to name a few), but their criteria is based on ethnicity and ancestry, not religion
but disagree with your conclusion, because the Law of Return is also about ethnicity and ancestry.
So it is your lack of knowledge that has brought about this situation, just as it was you that introduced the antisemitism sediment.
Moved to chat - sorry I didn't notice this for a couple of days
I will ask that @littleadv be nice. I have already been on the receiving end of this user to a small extent, and others have also mentioned him/her. It doesn't hurt to be nice to people
And criticising one country's policies based on religion does not make someone "anti" that religion or "anti" that country. And accusing someone of antisemitism just because that country is Israel is a very unpleasant thing to be accusing someone of
So again - I will ask @littleadv to tone it down a bit. He/she is openly arguing with people in a public forum, and doing that can get people blocked from that forum
Oh and also - @littleadv you enjoy being unkind to other people, but you flag people's comments as being unkind more often than I would expect
I agree with this.